Brimfield Universalist Church early 1900s
First Universalist Church
Brimfield, Ohio
Portage County
1820 - 1922
Church built: 1839, Destroyed by fire, rebuilt 1869 (Tallmadge Rd.)
1820s - 1922
Although it took until 1839 to build a church, Universalism flourished in the area, with many of the early settlers being Universalists. The Universalists called Timothy Bigelow in 1820 as their first pastor. Worship was conducted in local schoolhouses and member’s home. As William Kelso was connected with the Universalists, it is more than likely some of the meetings were held at the Kelso House, A Greek Revival house built in 1833 that served as Kelso home, tavern, ball room, and post office, an all-around community hub. Carolyn Henrietta Miller, a granddaughter of William, a gifted pianist, was the church organist from the late 70s or early 80s, until the church dissolved. The ladies of the Universalist Church served their annual Election Day suppers at the Kelso House tavern for several years. Although in later years the dinners were held at member’s homes. In 1919, the ladies “turned over the dinner to the Red Cross.” Presumably, this meant the funds raised. As the ladies were still looking for a home to host the dinner it appears that by this time, they were no longer holding the dinners at the Kelso tavern.1
Kelso House
Among the early preachers were E. Williams, A. Raynor, F. Loring, and S.A. Davis
By the mid-1880s the Universalists were established and large enough to consider building their own church. They re-organized as a Society in 1835 with the help of Rev. Andrew Wilson, and in 1839 erected a church. That building burned down in 1866, and a new church was built and dedicated in 1868. On May 18, 1922 – one-hundred and two years later -- the church officially dissolved and merged with the Kent Church which they had helped mother. For several years, until Kent was able to call their own minister, a minister travelled from Brimfield to Franklin Mills (now Kent) to preach.
>
Chancel Area ca 1900
Perhaps decorated for Easter?
[My guess is that identity of the person in each photo, from left to right:
Timothy Bigelow, Hosea Ballou, John Murray.]
1900 Brimfield Map
Universalist Church in Red.
Even though officially dissolved in 1922, newspaper notices mentioned at least two afternoon Christian Universalist services during the summer of 1923., as well as a Ladies of the Universalist Church hosting a social and dinner on July 12 at the Brimfield Town Hall.2, 3
In between the founding and those last days
In 1843, the church dismissed and expelled Rev. Freeman Loring, their pastor, for “unchristlike conduct.” This had to be for some sort of immoral conduct rather than theological error. For the Brimfield Universalists “morality and practical religion” after the example of Christ was the chief objective of their faith.4
Brimfield High School’s first graduating class held their commencement in the church in 1899.
Beginning in July 1919, the Christian Science Church rented space in the Universalist church for their services.5
And on Friday, February 4, 1921, the Brimfield high school boys and girls basketball teams played the two respective teams from Randolph high school at the Universalist Church. The admission was 25 cents. Sadly, there is no indication if this game was played in the sanctuary of a fellowship hall.6
Ministers:
Pre-1880s: E. Williams, A. Raynor, F. Loring, and S.A. Davis.7
After retiring from the Ravenna Church in 1898, the Rev. Andrew Wilson became the pastor of the Brimfield Church, which he promised to pastor “as long as he was able to ride to its doors.” Rev. Wilson died in 1911.
Most of the ministers were non-resident ministers. Resident ministers were Revs. Loring and J. S. Palmer. Other ministers in addition to Bigelow and Wilson were J. Whitney, G. Messinger, N. Doolittle, C. Shipman, G. Emerson, S. Carlton, H. Canfield, and Bacon.8
Prominent members included...9
Universalist Congregation?
The Thorndyke Family. Isaac Thorndyke built a nail factory in the township, the first in Ohio.
The Kelso Family: A foundational Brimfield family whose early settlers are tied closely to the town's early civic and religious history.
The Boosinger Family: One of the most prominent pioneer families in both Brimfield and neighboring Kent. They were heavily involved in the regional Universalist movement and later helped organize the expanded church body.
The Moulton Family: The Moultons were central to early township business and community leadership, operating out of the very same downtown street corners where the town's commercial and religious life intersected.
The Chapman and Cady Families: Recognized among the earliest settlers in Brimfield, members of these families were known to hold the progressive, "gentle optimist" theological views aligned with the Universalist Society.
The Haymaker and Olin Families: While frequently associated with the founding of the nearby Kent church in 1866, these families worked hand-in-hand with the original Brimfield congregation and its traveling ministers during the years the two communities shared resources.
The Snyder Family. Although probably not members, the family was clearly sympathetic to Universalist theology.
Universalist Church today as apartments
Notes:
1. Tribune, Kent. 1918-10-10.
2. ibid, 1923-07-19.
3. ibid, 1923-07-12.
4. Holm, James B., p. 172.
5. Tribune, 1919-07-17.
6. Tribune, 1921-02-03.
7. Holm, ibid.
8. Robinson, p. 143.
9. I was told that although there was also a Methodist Church in town, many of the town's influential folk attended the Universalist church and that the Universalists were deeply involved in the town's social life, the Election Eve dinner being an example. Many of the burial sites in Brimfield's Restland Cemetery are those of Universalists.
Postscript
After posting I received a delightful phone call from Shirley Miller whose husband is a descendent of the Kelso's via Carolyn Kelso Miller and also Tillman E. Synder who ran the town's general store and post office. It was Mrs. Miller who told me about Carolyn Kelso Miller playing the piano and organ at the church.
Photos
All but the current photo are from the files of Kelso House Museum. The photo file folder states "1900s." All the photos have been AI enhanced. The background photo has been colorized.
Resources:
Holm, James B., Portage Heritage. 1957.
The Tribune, Kent, Ohio, 1917-1923.
McMillen, Kristie, President & Historian, Kelso House Museum, Brimfield, OH.
Robinson, Elmo Arnold, The Universalist Church in Ohio, 1923.
Sherman, A. M., History of Brimfield, 1881.
Stranahan, H. B.(Editor, Pub.), 1900 Atlas of Portage County.
Western Reserve Historical Society, First Universalist Church (Brimfield, Ohio) Records.
Posted: November 6, 2026
Will be updated as new information becomes available.